Five Bedroom Single-Family Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, NY

 (1 - 3 of 3)
  1. Lake Dr, Shelter Island, Home For Sale

    $2,950,000 Lake Dr, Shelter Island, Home For Sale

    5 BR · Single Family · Shelter Island, NY
    A Private Oasis with plenty of space for all. This beautifully renovated home has many upgrades with a 20 X 40 Gunite heated pool with an outside shower. Maintenance-free Hardy Plank and Versatex exterior. A 500-square-foot storage in heated and h...
    Tools
    Theresa R. Andrew ·1 week ago on RealtyWW
  2. Modernized Captains House with Pool

    $1,950,000 Modernized Captains House with Pool

    5 BR · 2,300 sq. ft. · Single Family · Shelter Island, NY
    Old world charm with all the modern comforts. Complete renovation of Original Captain's home in time to enjoy summer with new kitchen, baths, HVAC, heated Gunite pool, garage and landscaping. Stylish decor and furnishings. Five bedrooms and three ...
    Tools
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·Over 4 weeks ago on LinkURealty
  3. Home For Sale In Shelter Island, New York

    $2,200,000 Home For Sale In Shelter Island, New York

    5 BR · 2,500 sq. ft. · Single Family · Shelter Island, NY
    Ram Island Cottage Located on the Tuthill Drive on Big Ram Island area of Shelter Island, sited on 1.35 acres ,Cottage is composed of Stone and Cedar. This bay view property overlooks Coecles Harbor and Mashomack Preserve. Property offers a heated...
    Tools
    Seth Madore ·Over 4 weeks ago on RealtyWW

SET LOCATION

Shelter Island, NY
[change location]
city
country

Category

(undo)Bedrooms

Price

to

Bathrooms

Show all options

Square Feet

to

Amenities

Refine By Keyword